Buckeye Bars

This easy, no bake recipe is the answer to your Chocolate and Peanut Butter craving! Buckeye Bars are decadent bites of candy that melt in your mouth!

Love this recipe? Sign up for Shugary Sweets email subscription and never miss out again! 

Buckeye Bars: no bake chocolate peanut butter candy that tastes like a Reese's peanut butter cup!

If you are a true lover of Chocolate and Peanut Butter then this recipe is made for you!

When it comes to eating candy, raise your hand if you tend to choose one with chocolate?

I have a few in my family who go for the Reese’s, Kit Kats, Rolos, and Heath bars. Every time.

Me and my hubby though, we prefer the chewy fruity…Swedish Fish, Starburst, and my personal favorite: Skittles.

Buckeye Bars: no bake chocolate peanut butter candy that tastes like a Reese's peanut butter cup!

But, back to the recipe! This past holiday I made a couple batches of our favorite recipe: Buckeyes. If you haven’t had one, you really should try them. (Also on my list? Sarah’s Buckeye graham crackers!)

Remember I said I made several batches? Well, after dipping the umpteenth buckeye in chocolate, it made me wonder if they could be made into bars instead. I mean really, how easy would that be, right?

After my first attempt, I knew I had the peanut butter layer nailed, but I had too thin a layer of chocolate on top (if you follow me on Instagram you would have seen this photo!) Instead of just adding more chocolate, I made a whole extra batch with a thicker layer of chocolate.

They were perfect. I decided to call them “Buckeye Bars.” But, after my oldest took one, he said they tasted like a Reese’s. SCORE!!!

You can call them Reese’s, or Buckeye Bars, but just promise you make a batch. I’ve seen other recipes that use graham crackers crushed into the bar, and while I’m sure that is delicious, this recipe has no crumbs. It’s melt in your mouth peanut butter, sugar, and butter!

I used Ghirardelli semi-sweet chocolate bars for the top layer. The chocolate melts so smooth, and tastes amazing.

If you don’t want your chocolate to “crack” when cutting your bars, don’t refrigerate these bars. And cut them as soon as the chocolate sets (about 30 minutes room temperature). I originally cut them into squares, but in an attempt to portion control and make them smaller, I cut each square into a triangle. So fun!

If you’re looking for more peanut butter treats…have you made these Peanut Butter Frosted Brownies yet? They are calling my name!

Buckeye Bars: no bake chocolate peanut butter candy that tastes like a Reese's peanut butter cup!

 I’m the candy contributor over at Food Fanatic. You can find this Buckeye Bars recipe and so much more!

Connect with Shugary Sweets! Be sure to follow me on my social media, so you never miss a post!

Facebook | Twitter | Google+ | Pinterest | instagram | Bloglovin’

Sign Up to receive an email in your inbox for each new recipe:

EMAIL SUBSCRIPTION

 

Buckeye Bars: no bake chocolate peanut butter candy that tastes like a Reese's peanut butter cup!

**There may be affiliate links in this post! By clicking on them, or purchasing recommended items I may receive a small compensation. However, I only recommend products I love! Thank you for supporting Shugary Sweets! See my disclosure policy for more info**

48 comments on “Buckeye Bars”

  1. SCORE!!!, indeed, Aimee! Love, love, love me some chocolate and PB…especially if it tastes like Reese’s PB cups! Thank you for sharing. Pinning!

  2. I’ve never made buckeyes, which is terrible! What kind of chocolate peanut butter lover am I? I love this bar version — the layers are picture perfect and the thicker the better! Pinned. 🙂

  3. Definitely one of my all time fav bars! Love your recipe 🙂

  4. dc

    Been making these for over 30 years from the Silver Palette cookbook. Yummy!! Nice to see them now and again!!

  5. These look great! I love Buckeyes but I don’t love the dipping. I’m a lazy baker

  6. Buckeyes in bar format, genius! So you don’t have to roll out all those buckeyes! Patience is not my virtue 🙂 Pinned of course!

  7. Chocolate and PB is right up there for me, and I love buckeyes. And in bar form too, oh yes!

  8. OMG. I’d eat the ENTIRE PAN. These would be dangerous. Love!

  9. My husband is the biggest PB fan I know. He would adore these bars!

  10. YUM! I love how these are so simple to make and no-bake! Doesn’t get much easier than that. I’ll have to wait to make them for a party or gathering, or I’ll eat the whole pan myself.

  11. Mir

    This stuff is pure crack, Aimee! I mean, I know coffee is your thing, but I have a hard time not mainlining chocolate and PB on a daily basis. These are definitely my favorite!

  12. Perfect for Valentine’s Day!! Love love love.

  13. Reese’s are my favorite candy bar and these just got added to my must-do list!

  14. I grew up eating these and love everything about them!

  15. My candy craving change depending on the day. Sometimes its chocolate and other times it is the chewy candy. These buckeye bars look so much easier than having to roll all the balls!

  16. Yum! peanut butter and chocolate are two of my favorite things!

  17. Donna

    Saw these in your email yesterday morning and loved them so much, I made them for the Super Bowl! I love buckeyes, and this was a great way to get the yummy without the tedious forming and dipping of the balls. I would like to suggest a few clarifications to the recipe though — since you recommend lining the pan with foil, could you say why in the instructions? I made mine in a 9×13 Pyrex, did not line it with foil, and had no issues getting the bars out. Also, for clarity you may want to edit the chocolate line in the ingredients — when I printed it out, it came out as “4 4 ounces ghirardelli semisweet chocolate bar” which momentarily threw me for a loop as 44 ounces is nearly 3 lbs of chocolate. I guessed you meant 4 x 4 oz for a total of 16 oz… which is what I did. My chocolate layer does not look as thick as yours does so I’m still wondering. They tasted yummy anyway!

    • I line mine with foil, because then I can lift the foil out of the pan, place it on a cutting board and get nice even cuts. Oooh, yeah, i see what you mean about the 44oz. Nope you had that right, 4 (4oz) bars. My middle pieces were thicker with chocolate, so maybe those are the ones in the photo? Glad you enjoyed the recipe, thanks for coming back with your tips!!

  18. These would be a whole lotta dangerous in my house!

  19. I will need my fat pants. These look and sound delicious!

  20. What incredible looking buckeye bars. I just love how easy they are to make and how little ingredients they require whilst still being so sweetly delicious (i bet)!

  21. I love Reese’s and buckeyes so really I’m obsessed with these bars either way!! and SUCH a genius idea to make them bars to save yourself on time!!

  22. I have become quite the lazy baker when it comes to truffles and candies lately…bars all the way!!! And these peanut butter chocolate wonders would totally not last the day in my house! Love that you remade them to have more chocolate!!!

  23. Love this! Looks so delicious 🙂

  24. OMG! I’m already craving these! Peanutbutter and chocolate are my akillesheal.. Maybe I’ll make these on Satursday with a heavy red wine. Yum!

    /F

    http://globalspicedblog.tumblr.com/

  25. You know these have my name written all, over. them. And I’m not sharing with anyone 😉

  26. For us poor fools on the other side of the water is powdered suger what we call icing sugar and do you know what the english eGhirardelli bar is please…

  27. Dinka Barbic

    Hi! Could these be made with peanuts instead of peanut butter? Because it’s kind of expensive here in Croatia. Regards!

  28. Pingback: Top Ten in February - Shugary Sweets

  29. I was trying to find inspiration for dinner, but saw this instead and now this is all I want.  Hey, peanut butter is good for you so this could count as dinner, right?

  30. Janet Fudge

    These do look and sound delicious, but aren’t they only a “Buckeye” because of their distinctive shape (shaped to look like the buckeye nut from the tree of the same name);  without that shape it’s just another peanut butter cup wanna-be. I doubt that any Ohioan would call these a Buckeye, even if they are delicious.

    • Having lived in Ohio for 8 years, I’m pretty sure none of my neighbors complained when I brought them a plate of these “buckeye bars.” After all, it’s just a name. And they taste EXACTLY like the traditional treat, only in a “bar form.” Making it easier for many people to enjoy!

  31. Could you use chocolate chips instead of the candy bars? If so how many cups would you use? I have the chocolate chips on hand……thanks!

  32. So easy and so good. Family loves them too.

  33. Becca

    How much chocolate? I’m using chocolate chips and guessing 16oz? But it says bar…so maybe it’s supposed to be 1 chocolate bar? = /

  34. JO

    LOL..as an Ohioan..you betcha I would call these Buckeye Bars and not snub my nose at them!! So much faster then rolling and dipping-Yea!! I do have a question though…I would make Buckeye Balls for Christmas starting end of November and keep cool and in covered containers and they would be fine till Christmastime…
    Have you found the same to be true with the bars–just asking as the PB isnt encased in chocoate as balls are?? thanks in advance for your response!

  35. Lori

    Going to try this. Should the pan be chilled before covering with the chocolate? I normally would chill the balls before dipping.

  36. Cindy

    My peanut butter part seemed to soft,chocalate melted as soon as you touched it.would have liked it to be firm.

  37. Can you use dark chocolate chips instead of bars?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.