Chocolate Oatmeal Cream Pies made into a football shape for Game Day! Snack on these soft and chewy treats with a creamy filling while you cheer on your favorite team.
Game Day Dessert
Need a new dessert idea for watching the Big Game this weekend? This recipe puts a football spin on an old favorite.
Did I mention there’s CHOCOLATE involved, too?
Chocolate Oatmeal Cream Pies are so easy to make with a sweet frosting filling. Shaping them into footballs is simpler than you think.
They look amazing on the dessert table!
This recipe is just like the classic, Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream pie, except made with chocolate. Soft and chewy with a perfect cream center, melted white chocolate forms “laces” on the top.
If you love these cookies, be sure to try our favorite no bake Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies too!
Shortening. Butter flavored Crisco works best. You’ll use it in both the cookie dough and the filling. Do not substitute butter or oil.
Brown sugar. Either light or dark brown sugar can be used. Dark brown sugar brings out a stronger molasses flavor.
Molasses. You need regular molasses (not black strap or “dark” versions, which are much more bitter).
Vanilla Extract. Use my homemade vanilla extract recipe for best results!
Marshmallow fluff. Or “marshmallow cream” for the cream filling!
Quick oats. These are processed more finely than other oats. Don’t use whole rolled oats or steel cut here.
White chocolate. This gets melted to make the football lace design on top. Candy melting wafers or regular bars of white chocolate both work well.
First, make the chocolate oatmeal cookie dough.
- Drop the dough by the spoonful onto a lined cookie sheet. Use your hands the shape the dough into ovals.
- Bake for about 7 minutes. When the cookies have JUST started to brown at the edges, take them out of the oven.
Make the cream filling.
- Frost the flat side of one cooled cookie.
- Press another cookie on top. Repeat until you’ve turned all the cookies into oatmeal cream pies.
Add the white chocolate:
- Melt white chocolate and spoon it into a ziploc bag. Pipe the laces to resemble a football.
- Let the chocolate set for a few minutes before serving.
Tips and Tricks
- If the cookies get too round in the oven, pinch the ends to sharpen the “point” of each football. Do this while the cookies are still warm, just after baking.
- For cleaner lines on the oatmeal cream pie footballs, transfer the white chocolate to a plastic zipped bag with the corner snipped off. Then pipe the chocolate onto the cookies, just like you would with frosting.
- These still look and taste great made as regular oatmeal cream pies! Feel free to bake them as regular round cookies. You can drizzle white chocolate over them in whatever design you like, or omit it entirely.
- Use a tablespoon sized cookie scoop to ensure the cookies are equally sized. Equally sized cookies make the best looking cream pies!
No, I do not recommend using butter in this oatmeal cream pie recipe. The shortening reacts with the other ingredients to make the cookies super chewy. Butter will result in a thinner, flatter cookie.
Yes, these Chocolate Oatmeal Cream Pie Footballs can be frozen and stored for the Game Day. Transfer to freezer bags once cooled.
They’ll keep well for up to 2 months in the freezer.
This recipe makes enough cookies and filling for about 18 assembled cream pies. Each time I made the recipe, I get about 36 individual cookies from the dough.
More Game Day Recipes
A Game Day dessert for all the football fans in your life! This recipe for Chocolate Oatmeal Cream Pie Footballs adds sweetness and fun to your game watching party.