Pumpkin Coffee Creamer

If you love fall coffee house drinks, you’ve got to try making this easy, Homemade Pumpkin Coffee Creamer!

Be sure to sign up for my email…new recipes in your inbox!

If you love fall coffee house drinks, you've got to try making this easy, Homemade Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer!

I am a coffee creamer addict. I am “that” person who ads and commercials target. I purchase bottles of coffee creamer every week in every flavor. Rotating the new, seasonal flavors with my favorite year round flavors (french vanilla, hazelnut, and chocolate).

And the more in love with a creamer I get, the more coffee I drink. I am already a coffee addict, but seriously, this time of year it intensifies.

Why? Because Pumpkin Spice coffee creamer gets me every time. (dare I even tell you how much I love it in pumpkin spiced coffee???) Pumpkin coffee + Pumpkin creamer = JOY.

Pumpkin Spice Coffee creamer: easy, delicious coffee creamer made it home! #copycat

I learned awhile ago how to make my own coffee creamer when I tried this French Vanilla Coffee Creamer recipe. It’s not difficult. Seriously it’s two ingredients…plus whatever flavoring you want. But, sometimes, I forget how easy it is to make. So today, I’m sharing my favorite recipe for coffee creamer…with a pumpkin spice twist!

By mixing one 14oz can of sweetened condensed milk with 1 1/2 cup heavy cream (or whole milk) you have the base of a sweet and creamy coffee creamer. Add in vanilla beans for a delicious french vanilla creamer. But for today’s recipe, we will use some pure pumpkin and spices. We will also heat up that pumpkin spice because you don’t want any gritty seasonings in your creamer. I let mine simmer for about 20 minutes, whisking occasionally.

Okay. So now you have this rich, creamy Pumpkin Spice coffee creamer. What now? I suggest you brew up a delicious pot of coffee asap!

Pumpkin Spice Coffee creamer: easy, delicious coffee creamer made it home! #copycat

I created a fun little group on facebook and I’d love for you to join in! It’s a place where you can share YOUR favorite recipes, ask questions, and see what’s new with Shugary Sweets (so that you never miss a new recipe)! If you’d like to check it out, you can request to join HERE.

Connect with Shugary Sweets! Be sure to follow me on my social media, so you never miss a post!

Facebook | Twitter | Google+ | Pinterest | instagram 

Sign up to receive an email in your inbox for each new recipe:



Pumpkin Coffee Creamer

Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes

If you love fall coffee house drinks, you've got to try making this easy, Homemade Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer!


  • 1 1/2 cup heavy cream, divided
  • 1/4 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 1/4 tsp allspice
  • 1/4 cup pure pumpkin
  • 1 can (14oz) sweetened condensed milk


  1. In a medium saucepan, whisk together 1/2 cup heavy cream, cinnamon, allspice and pumpkin puree. Simmer over low for about 15-20 minutes. Remove from heat and cool completely.
  2. Once cooled, whisk in the remaining heavy cream and sweetened condensed milk. Pour into mason jars. Keep for up to one week in the refrigerator.
  3. **SHAKE WELL before using


**I like to store in mason jars and give one away to a friend. You can also cut this recipe in half, making one half with vanilla bean and the other with pumpkin. ENJOY.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram


Looking for more Pumpkin recipes? You’ve come to the right place!


These Pumpkin Muffins with Maple Glaze would be the perfect pair to your Pumpkin coffee.


Pumpkin Spice Biscotti: yeah, pretty sure this would go nicely with your coffee too….

**Le Creuset provided me a French Press set for review, and an additional set for one reader. No other compensation was received. All opinions are 100% my own! There are affiliate links in this post too!


About Aimee

Aimee is a dessert lover (specifically rice krispie treats), workout enthusiast, self-taught foodie, and recipe creator.

Learn more about Aimee.

Affiliate Disclosure:**There may be affiliate links in this post! By clicking on them, or purchasing recommended items I may receive a small compensation. However, I only recommend products I love! Thank you for supporting Shugary Sweets! See my disclosure policy for more info**

Get My Free Email Course
Become a Better Baker—no more box mixes! Discovery your new “signature” desserts!


Posted on September 18, 2013

Comments & Reviews

  1. I cannot wait to try this!!!! I’ve been so disappointed with two different pumpkin syrups I bought on Amazon, so I can’t wait to give this a try! 

  2. I need flavor creamers that are sugar free. Can you please tell us what we need to make without sugar and without fat if possible?

  3. I would like to know if this can be frozen. I love the Bailey’s Pumpkin Spice Creamer but have to wait until fall for it, so I am anxious to try this. If you could please advise me.
    Thank you for your time.

  4. Quick question, on your pumpkin creamer recipe you mention “Keep for up to one week in the refrigerator.” Do you mean keep for up to one week before using or is that how long the creamer will remain good for?

    1. Nope, you can use immediately. I usually tell people it’s good for a week in the fridge. However, I usually follow my milk’s expiration date to determine how long to keep the creamer. And, when I make homemade creamer it’s usually gone within a week anyways 🙂

  5. I’m not much of a cook, but this looks easy even I could try it. Silly question, can you make this in larger batches and freeze for later use?

  6. My dear friend had a stroke last year in October. Since then she complains that her taste buds have changed. She really likes coffee and sweets. I will make her some of your pumpkin coffee creamer and see if she likes it. She loves the homemade foods I bring her from time to time. Thanks for the ideas.

  7. As much as I’d love to give it away, I’d have to keep it for myself and invite those who I would love to give it away to, to enjoy it with me. =)

  8. I am that coffee creamer addict as well. If I got this press I would keep it for myself but share lots of excellently flavored coffee with others!

  9. A girl after my own heart!…….I love pumpkin spice!…and other holiday creamers…Hazelnut and Italian Sweet Cream the rest of the year…thanks for sharing!

  10. This french press looks amazing! My hubby and I are addicted to pressed coffee, but the glass presses last about one month in our hands. I’ve been waiting until Black Friday to find a more durable press, and this one looks great! As much as I’d love to share it with someone else, I’ll be keeping it if I’m blessed enough to win. 🙂

  11. I am torn about keeping or giving away this set — IF I were to win! This is such a beautiful set!! The pumpkin spice creamer sounds good right about now! Central PA is beginning to really feel like fall!

  12. I never knew flavored creamer was so easy to make. I can’t wait to try the pumpkin spice creamer. I would keep the set and enjoy coffee with friends!

  13. I’ll give it to my mom for Christmas with a batch of the pumpkin creamer that I’ll whip up using your recipe. Thanks for the great contest and the delicious recipe.

  14. What a beautiful set! And thanks for the Pumpkin Spice creamer recipe. I get tired of casing the grocery stores because they can’t keep it in stock.

  15. Gorgeous! Something about that blue…love to win, my grandson is getting married, so this would be a lovely housewarming token…

  16. Oh… I would have to keep it for ME 🙂 I absolutely love LeCreuset wares, I have many. I am such a coffee fanatic (good coffee 🙂 that is)this would be great to enjoy.

  17. If I won this french press set I would keep it for myself! I don’t know anyone else who appreciates coffee as much as I do! French press is the only way to drink coffee.

  18. I would keep it myself…. especially if it is blue, it would look perfect in my kitchen. Need a new french press so that I can have one for coffee and one for tea. I use my french press of cold pressed coffee… makes the best cup of coffee.

  19. I would probably keep it…It is in my favorite color…and I have yet to convert anyone to loving French pressed coffee as much as I do 🙁 They truly don’t know what they are missing out on.

  20. This is an amazing give away and I would love to win a new coffee press set. (And blue is my favorite color) And I would love to thank you for all the delicious recipes!! I have tried a few of them and plan on working my through more. Thank you for the wonderful opportunity to share wonderfully delicious dishes for my friends and family

  21. This set is gorgeous!!! My dad is a huge french press fan and my parents have been remodeling a house…it would make a wonderful housewarming!!

  22. I would love to win the Le Creuset French Press Set and of course, I would keep it for myself.. along with some pumpkin muffins, I would be set for fall mornings……….

  23. I’d keep it but invite friends over to share coffee and conversation with! And it gives me an excuse to bake some pumpkin scones and pumpkin biscotti!! 🙂

  24. I love a french press as it works well for my coffee drinking husband AND my tea drinking self! And really, who isn’t thrilled when pumpkin season arrives? 😉

  25. I would definitely keep it! Thank you for the great recipe! I love everything pumpkin but this Pumpkin Spice Creamer will go perfectly with my Pumpkin Spice coffee!

  26. I use a coffee press every day and would love a new one and a teakettle. I do love your blog and your FB page. I love to bake and while I am spending a lot of time of rolled and decorated sugar cookies, I have to take a break and make bread, bar cookies or something different just to use those muscles some more. I love food, I love to bake, and I would love to win this! Thanks for the opportunity!

  27. That is a tough question! I’d be very torn between keeping it for myself and giving it away… I do need a new kettle so I’d want to keep that part even if I gave away the others, but then it would be a shame to break up the set… either way, it would definitely make me (or someone in my family) very happy!

  28. I am sooo glad I stumbled on this site! LOVE love love pumpkin creamer and haven’t found it out yet! I have the ingredients to make it so I now have the recipe…cannot wait! I also love the extra pumpkin recipes.
    As for the coffee set, everyone keeps telling me to get a french press and grind my beans fresh and I have been hesitant due to cost. This blue though…Oh My! I love it! I think I just found the blue I need in my kitchen with the yellow! 😀 I think a trip to my outlet mall to see the Le Creuset things is on for this weekend! So beautiful!

  29. I would totally use this every single day. We had a french press and darling husband broke it washing it one day (bless his heart)…

  30. Oh what a beautiful set! I would love to win it for me and then buy a set for my mom! Thanks for a chance to win it and for sharing such yummy pumpkin recipes!

  31. I would probably keep it at my parents home, as they are huge coffee drinkers as well, and I am always there visiting. Also, love this recipe! Can’t wait to try it!

  32. I am so excited to try this recipe and I would love to win the giveaway. I absolutely love coffee. Drink it every single morning. Thanks for the recipe!

  33. I would give it to my mom…as an upgrade to the one I bought her years ago. That way when we get to visit we can enjoy it together 🙂 She would never buy herself a “treat” of sorts, but wouldn’t leave another to go without a thing…

  34. I will definitely keep it for myself as I am a coffee snob and a coffee addict….luv, luv luv coffee and great coffee brewing systems

  35. Hmm…if I win I will gift the french press and mugs to my in-laws (they love french pressed coffee and we already have one) and keep the tea pot, we need one.

  36. My OWN pumpkin coffee creamer?!? You evil mastermind! 😉 Now I’ll just be making pumpkin spice lattes all year around. No one can stop me mwhahahahaha.

    1. Oops! See? I was stuck on your idea of gifting one jar of creamer and keeping one. I meant I’d keep both jars 😉
      As for the french press, ohhhh man. That’s been on my list of wants for YEARS. I’d have to keep it 🙂

  37. I would love to have the pumpkin flavor, but I don’t care much for creamer. Is there any reason this wouldn’t be ok made with regular milk if I sweetened it a little?

  38. If I win,, I’m totally keeping it! I need to convince my friends I’m a coffee snob too! Can’t wait to try it with this creamer!

  39. I would probably keep it even though I don’t need another one. The set is so cute though. I have a thing for all things coffee.

  40. I’d have a hard time giving it away, since it would be a birthday gift to me if I won. 🙂 but I’d definitely use it with sweet company.

  41. I’m totally going to make this creamer for my hubby who loves all things pumpkin. I think my son might like it too, but at two and a half, who can say.

  42. Press for hubby because he is the coffee connoisseur, teapot for mom because she is Irish and mugs for me so that they could make the delicious beverages for me to enjoy:)

  43. Well, I already have a french press, but it’s not nearly as cute as this one. So, I’d probably keep it and pass my old one on to a friend.

  44. OH gosh, this looks amazing!!! I’d either keep it for myself or give it to my sister as a bridal shower gift, depends if she has a whole set or not yet…..

  45. I would prob keep it for myself! I have given a french press to so many of my family members as gifts but haven’t gotten one for myself! And I know that the coffee is just so much better!! (I need to get one!)

  46. I think if I win, this would be perfect for our family’s Christmas gift exchange. Although I would love to keep it for myself! It’s really beautiful, as is all Le Creuset.

  47. Omg, DEFINITELY going to keep it! Something I’ve wanted but unwilling to spend the money on for myself. And bless you for this recipe! Every year I try in vein to find the pumpkin spice creamer in stores, to no avail. I’m sure this tastes far better than it would anyway! Thanks!!

  48. So beautiful! Love the blue color. I would love to keep it, however I think I would give it to my mom! Love this creamer recipe too! Incredible!

  49. I would definitely keep the set! The blue is gorgeous and the set is darling.
    Not to mention, my favorite cooking vessels are made by Le Creuset!

    1. Obviously I haven’t had enough coffee this morning to pay attention to what I was commenting on this time…I would love to have one to make coffee. I used to have one and it got broken.

  50. I would keep the set for myself 😉 Thanks for the recipe! It’s nice to see a natural alternative to the junk-filled ones in the stores.

  51. I LOVE anything pumpkin!!!! So excited to see this beautiful coffee set! I will definitely add this pumpkin spice creamer to my grocery list! Thanks!

  52. I would love to have this set at my house. The red is absolutely beautiful! I love coffee and would keep this to make my morning coffee and anytime I need another pick me up! What a beautiful set. Thank YOU for sharing it with one of us!

  53. My birthday is this Saturday, if I win I’m keeping for myself! Awesome giveaway and I can’t wait to make the pumpkin creamer.

  54. I would keep it! I am a coffee addict I can’t believe I never thought to make my own creamer! I am making the recipe now just waiting for the pan to cool to finish it!!

  55. I would totally keep the set for myself! I want to impress my friends, although like you said-they know the “real’ me!

  56. I’d definitely keep it for myself; my dad already has a fancy french press of his own, and having my own would be nice. Nothing says a lazy Saturday morning like a good cup of french pressed coffee.

  57. I will keep the set myself. I have one of their tea pots already but I would give away my orange one and keep the beautiful blue set for me. Thanks for the giveaway.

  58. I would keep it to myself. I love coffee cups, my hubby says I have too many, but what does he know anyway. I love sipping warm coffee, tea, hot cocoa in the winter, and fall months.

  59. To win such a beautiful set — I’d keep it and invite my friends for coffee.
    The creamer is so easy and tasty. My husband is thrilled.

  60. My entire family loves coffee!! I enjoy trying new brews and techniques, always in the pursuit my “favorite” The press would definitely be well loved in my house 🙂

  61. If I won, it would definitely stay in my possession. My 21 year old French Press cracked just a few weeks ago. Since then all of our vehicles have broken down and yesterday our heat/AC unit went out. It doesn’t look like I’ll be replacing it anytime soon! I win here would be SO appreciated! Thanks for the opportunity!

  62. I use a French press, would love this one! What a fun recipe. We get together for coffee and I know the mom’s would love this!

  63. I am the only one in my family that drinks coffee, so I would be keeping this one for myself. ( not to sound selfish) This set is gorgeous! Thank you

  64. This is so lovely. Of COURSE I’m keeping it for myself! Love this site by the way. That indulgent pumpkin creamer? Oh, nice…..

  65. I’d love to set this on my counter! I use huge cups for my hot drinks, would love to have some that would keep my drink warm for a longer time!

  66. I would keep this to use for myself, and for when our children come home to visit, when we have company & when we also have quests. 🙂

  67. Well, this may just be selfish, but I’d love it for myself! Most of my family are not coffee drinkers (!?!) and my friends are lazy enough that they don’t make coffee at home, they just buy it at coffee kiosks. Me? I’m a stay home mom, and would love to “class up” my morning coffee!

  68. I would split the set, keeping the press and one cup for myself and giving the kettle and one cup to my tea-drinking best girlfriend. That way we can each have a cuppa ‘together’ when we’re chatting and still in our own houses.

    Thanks for the creamer recipe. I’m hitting the store this afternoon!

  69. I will give it to my husband as a gift, since he is the coffee maker and I’m just the coffee drinker in the house. 🙂 So I guess that is kind of like giving it and keeping it.

  70. OMG! And here I thought they marketed all those creamer flavors just to ME! I love this post…and all the related recipes…I’m off to find you on bloglovin’ and I’m entering the giveaway for sure! You’ve got a brand new fan!

    Fresh Eggs Daily

  71. I have no idea!!! 🙂 I have a cherry-themed kitchen, so it would depend on if I had a choice of color. I would love a French press set. I’ve never used one, but always hear how wonderful the coffee is when one is used. I guess it’ll be a last-minute decision! 🙂

  72. I would totally keep it for myself! It is the last piece I need to complete my coffee bar! Also, thank you for the pumpkin spice creamer recipe. I made some last week, but didn’t think to heat it up and it was super gritty!

  73. I can’t believe its that simple! SO creative. Wow, that will save me money … and give me a cup of pumpkin coffee without starbucks! This just put the cozy in fall coffee!

  74. #1. Why have I not been making my own coffee creamer
    #2. I’m keeping the set, then inviting friends over to enjoy it with me!

  75. I’d like to say I’d give it as a gift but no, I’d probably keep it for myself! I’d invite people over to drink coffee with me, though!

  76. If I win, I would give the set to my sis-in-law! We are both avid french press coffee drinkers and both happened to move around the same time AND both lost our french presses in the move! I have been able to a new one since, but she has not. She would absolutely LOVE this!

    And I am definitely going to go make this coffee creamer right now 🙂 🙂

  77. Can’t wait to try your coffee creamer. I love this time of year for all of the seasonal coffee creamers. I am drinking pumpkin pie spice creamer in my coffee right now. I would keep the set for myself. My kettle leaks and I need a new one.

  78. I would keep it for me! I’ve never had a french press before & would also love to feel like a grownup while drinking my coffee 😉 Now that it’s FINALLY cooling down around here I’m all about pumpkin everything & fall decorating!

  79. As a busy mom of two small children – I would love to treat my husband and myself to a delicious coffee – freshly made with the Marseille Le Creuset French Press set early mornings before the kids wake up – I’ll be able to drink slowly while in good conversation and enjoy every sip – In addition, the homemade pumpkin creamer would be a nice treat to celebrate fall – thank you for the recipe!

  80. I’d love to say that I would be willing to give it away, but honestly? Well, I’d keep the set for myself, but I’d share the coffee with visitors! I promise!

  81. Came here from Pinterest to see the creamer recipe. Looks great! I’m going to try it as soon as possible. I would have to keep the set for myself because I’ve never tried French pressed coffee, but my sister raves about it.

  82. Oh, mighty Universe/Raffle Gods, please may I win this? I love french press, I adore Le Creuset, I am a coffee snob/purist, AND today is my 40th birthday! I deserve it, right? 😉

  83. I have the white Le Creuset mugs as part of my everyday china and just LOVE them! I would LOVE this set to add to my LC collection!

  84. OMG I’m so excited, I had no idea Le Creuset made French presses! I’d keep this for myself to remind me of my study-abroad days in college 🙂

  85. I might give it away as a gift this Christmas…or I might keep it. I’ll let you know when I win 🙂 Love this easy creamer…you have me thinking of making my favorite creamer now!

  86. I am so excited about this homemade creamer! My friend has some at her house the other day and I have been craving it ever since! So making this tomorrow! Oh and I am a coffee addict to, we can have a group or something, and I would totally keep them for myself!!!

  87. I would have to keep it! It is so beautiful and I’ve been dying to switch to a french press…just waiting for my current coffee maker to die!

  88. I can so relate to this post…i am THAT person that puts waaay too much creamer in my coffee, but it’s just sooo good!! Also, nothing makes me happier than to see pumpkin spice lattes on the menu at Starbucks and pumpkin spice creamer at the markets. Thanks for sharing this super easy recipe!

      1. I would invite all my friends over for a wonderful cup of french press coffee and we would all go “hurray” then everyoneone would order one just like the beautiful Le Creuset I just won from their company and from shugarysweets. !!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *