Here’s the thing friends. Shortbread cookies can be very addicting.
Butterscotch Shortbread cookies? Well, let’s just say I warned you.
Shortbread cookies are one of the easiest cookies to make. But for some reason, these gave me a little bit of a challenge. See normally, I make the dough, wrap it in saran wrap, chill it, slice and bake.
But today I was a little hurried. And I browned the butter (something I don’t usually do with shortbread cookies). I wanted to infuse a little extra butterscotch flavor into these, so browning the butter had to be done. But the dough wasn’t ‘right’. And I didn’t want to chill it (did I mention I was in a hurry?). So instead of throwing it out, I did what any genius baker would do. I added an egg.
Seriously, I had no idea if it would work or not (I don’t normally put eggs in my shortbread).
IT WORKED. And these cookies are amazing. Please trust me. Here they are all sliced and purrrttyyy for you (yes, I ate the corners. Had to taste test before photo ops).Okay. So you’re trying to eat healthy. These are great stored in the freezer too! You can just pull one or two out for dessert! I mean, you need to reward yourself with cookies, right? Hmmm, maybe that’s why I can’t lose weight!!
Love Butterscotch? Love Shortbread? Here are a few other fun recipes:
Triple Chip Revel Bars: fudgy cookie bars made with butterscotch, dark chocolate and milk chocolate morsels
Butterscotch Marshmallow Bars: Ooey, gooey delicious butterscotch and chocolate bars (and marshmallow, duh)!
Triple Chocolate Caramel Butterscotch Bread: The name says it all, easy to make and even easier to eat!
Simple Shortbread Cookies: sandwich two classic shortbread cookies with Nutella
Jingles Cookies: shortbread cookies with anise extract (copycat Jingles)- can use any color sprinkles for year round enjoyment!
Never miss another Shugary update! Connect with Shugary Sweets here:
Facebook | Twitter | BlogLovin | Pinterest | Instagram | Google+
Butterscotch Shortbread Bars
Ingredients
Instructions
I’m such a fool for butterscotch. Love these!
Thanks Cassie. I could put butterscotch in anything and love it!!
I think I just died and went to heaven!!! Finally, an incredible butterscotch recipe…and as a shortbread bar – even better!
Carol, you need to try this! I think you really will find this recipe is from heaven 🙂
These definitely look delicious, Aimee! I heart butterscotch in everything and this shortbread looks perfect!
I love shortbread and the addition of butterscotch sounds amazing! I love when you think a recipe won’t turn out and it turns out delicious 🙂
Hi Lisa! I’ve had my share of fails in creating recipes, but was so excited that this one worked!
Butterscotch and me, we are BFFs. Um, I think that I need these. Which is why I can’t lose weight either….
I’ve been back at the gym for the New Year, but then I come home and eat half a dozen cookies. Sad.
I adore shortbread and have never made butterscotch shortbread! I’ve also never tried your method of rolling out the dough. Fun and delicious!
Bars are so fun. I didn’t really use a roller though, I just pressed it with my fingers and palms of my hands! The dough is too sticky for a rolling pin (I think).
What a great idea – these are so simple but the texture looks great! Glad you pushed through and didn’t give up on them!
Agreed! I was happy the egg didn’t change the texture of shortbread (or give it a weird taste). It just helped bind the dough together!! Thanks for stopping by!
I spent all day eating my friends’ leftover and unwanted butterscotch Sees’ hard candies…needless to say, you have me convinced that I have not yet met my butterscotch quota yet. Must give this a try! I’ll be making homemade Twix soon, and I think this would make a great crust.
Homemade Twix sounds amazing! YUM.
Butterscotch is one of my favorites!! And I am with you on the whole eating sweets and not loosing any weight…that’s got to be my problem. But with bars this delicious around, how can you say no?
I can’t say no. That is the problem 😉
I love butterscotch, but never tried it with shortbread! I bet these are irresistible, how you could you stop with the corners!
Oh I only stopped at the corners BEFORE the photo. No stopping after the pictures were done!
I loveee shortbread, and the addition of butterscotch is genius! I somehow always forget that I need to chill shortbread dough and then get so mad when I realize I can’t bake them right away haha Good to know that the egg worked!
That darn chilling factor!! Yep, the egg was my little miracle worker!
Happy New Year Aimee! I love shortbread and never thought to add butterscotch to it – sounds delish! I’m back from holidays and can’t wait to catch up on all my favorite blogs – yours included!
Hope you had a nice holiday!!! Glad you are back (and stopping by)!
ok, i’m convinced, I don’t bake with butterscotch nearly enough. and judging by the drool dripping down my chin looking at this recipe and these photos — I obviously have to change that!!
Haha. I love butterscotch. Seriously I could bake with it daily. That and lemon.
OH goodness, another yummy one to try! Thank you!!
Looks so yummy! I love butterscotch.
KC
Lose weight? LOL. I’ve done nothing but gain since I started blogging. 🙂 The calories would be totally worth it in these shortbread bars, though. And with butterscotch?!?! Squeeeee, yes please!
Oh so yummy!!! Just made it and our house is deliciously smelling good! Thanks a lot!!
Do you think these would work using Splenda?
OK, I tried these and maybe I did something wrong, but the dough was definitely not “crumbly” after I added the flour. So I kept adding more flour until it got to “crumbly.” The end result was OK, but a little dry. Did I do something wrong? I’m willing to give them another try because they did taste good, it was just the texture that was an issue.