This Halloween dessert is a little spooky, a little silly, and a lot delicious! Add a cookie graveyard to your Dirt Pudding Cake and invite the ghouls and ghosts out to party!
Table of Contents
Graveyard Dirt Dessert
I’m a little giddy about how adorable this Halloween Dirt Cake turned out. I took a classic Dirt Cake recipe and decorated it for the upcoming holiday by making it look like a graveyard.
A few candy pumpkins adds just the right colorful touch!
Not familiar with Dirt Cake?
It’s a “cake” made from a combination of chocolate pudding, cool whip and cream cheese. You add crushed Oreos on top to make it look like dirt!
Usually, you’d add things like gummy worms to the pudding to double down on the garden dirt theme (you can see it served in trifles and clean garden pots at parties too).
Kids always love dirt cake and eating it always reminds me that food is supposed to be FUN. Decorating this dessert was a blast; this would be a great recipe for kids to help make.
In this twist on the classic, the crushed cookies become graveyard dirt! Whether you’re having a party or staying home to enjoy the day this year, this cake will make a perfect centerpiece for your dessert table.
How to Make Tombstones
The “tombstones” dotted on the top of the dirt cake are key for making it look like a graveyard.
To make them, dip nutter butter cookies in melted white chocolate.
Let the chocolate set, then use a frosting bag or ziploc bag with the corner cut out to pipe “RIP” onto each cookie using melted milk chocolate.
If you’re handy with your frosting bag you could even get creative and add other fun designs or names to the tombstones!
Once the chocolate is set, poke the bottoms into the top of the pudding cake, arranging the scene however you like.
- Cookies – I like classic Oreo sandwich cookies for this recipe. Crush the cookies first (filling included)!
- Instant Pudding – Chocolate pudding mix works best for the “dirt” theme but Vanilla Pudding mix tastes good here too.
- Cool whip – If frozen, let the cool whip thaw before using. You can also make homemade stabilized whipped cream instead too.
- Milk – Any variety of milk works here! You can use whole milk, low fat, non-dairy etc.
- Candy corn and pumpkins – Arrange these around the headstones to complete your scene!
- Tombstones– you’l need Nutter Butter cookies (or Milanos), white chocolate, and milk chocolate.
Add the crushed Oreos on top, arrange your pumpkins and candy corn with your Nutter Butter tomb stones and you have a fun, spooky Graveyard Dirt Cake.
Powdered sugar, cream cheese and butter get mixed with the pudding, then you fold in the cool whip to create a dreamy, fluffy pudding cake base!
Dirt Pudding Cake Variations
Easter Dirt Cake– topped with Peeps and pastel candies.
Classic Dirt Cake– with chocolate filling.
Gummi Dirt Cake– with vanilla pudding and gummi worms.
Enjoy your dirt cake within 3 days for best taste. Store tightly covered with cling wrap in the fridge! Keep in mind that the cookies tombstones may get soft after a day or two.
When a dirt cake comes out runny, it’s usually because you accidentally used cook and serve pudding mix! Make sure the box says Instant pudding mix before adding it to this cake recipe.
Yes. I love this with vanilla pudding too, or you’re welcome to experiment with your favorite pudding flavors. Make sure it’s a pudding that tastes good with chocolate cookies!
More Halloween Recipes
- Halloween Cookie Cups
- Spider Rice Krispie Treats
- Halloween Muddy Buddies
- Spooky 7 Layer Dip
- Jack O Lantern Cookies
Halloween Dirt Cake
- 1 package Oreo cookies, crushed (with filling) 15.5 oz
- ¼ cup unsalted butter softened
- 1 package cream cheese, softened 8 oz
- ¾ cup powdered sugar
- 2 ¾ cup milk any variety
- 2 boxes instant chocolate pudding mix 3.4 oz each
- 12 oz Cool Whip
For the graveyard
- 12 Nutter butter cookies
- 10 oz Ghirardelli white chocolate melting wafers
- 1 cup assorted candy corn and pumpkins
- ¼ cup melted Ghirardelli chocolate wafers
- In a large mixing bowl, cream together the butter, cream cheese, and powdered sugar until fluffy. Set aside.
- In a bowl, whisk together the milk with instant pudding, until no clumps appear.
- Pour pudding mix into cream cheese mixture. Beat until well blended, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed.
- Fold in Cool Whip.
- Arrange in a 13 x 9 by pouring half the Oreos in the bottom, topped with the filling, then the remaining Oreos on top.
- Refrigerate for at least 2 hours until set.
- For the graveyard, melt white chocolate according to package directions. Dunk almost the entire Nutter butter into the candy coating. Lay on parchment paper to set.
- Melt chocolate wafers according to package directions. Spoon into a ziploc bag and snip off the corner. Pipe "RIP" onto the white chocolate dipped "tombstones".
- Arrange Nutter butters (after they have set) onto the dirt pudding cake right before serving. Add candy corn and candy pumpkins to the scene. ENJOY.
- How Should You Store Dirt Cake? Enjoy your dirt cake within 3 days for best taste. Store tightly covered with cling wrap in the fridge! Keep in mind that the cookies “tombstones” may get soft after a day or two.
- Why did my dirt cake come out runny? When a dirt cake comes out runny, it’s usually because you accidentally used cook and serve pudding mix! Make sure the box says “INSTANT” pudding mix before adding it to this cake recipe.
- Can I use other flavors of pudding in dirt cake? Yes. I love this with vanilla pudding too, or you’re welcome to experiment with your favorite pudding flavors. Make sure it’s a pudding that tastes good with chocolate cookies!
Skip the boring grown up desserts and feel like a kid again! This Graveyard Dirt Cake is tasty fun for the whole family.