Toffee Chocolate Chip Valentine’s Day Cheeseball

This is the perfect dip to serve on Valentine’s day! It’s a chocolate chip cheeseball with toffee chips mixed in and then covered in holiday sprinkles! My kids are requesting this dip as their after school snack on Valentine’s Day! And apples are the perfect dipping tool, too!

Love this recipe? Sign up for Shugary Sweets email subscription and never miss out again!

Chocolate Chip Toffee Dip for Valentine's Day. Easy to make and deliciously addicting! #chocolatechip

Chocolate Chip Toffee Dip for Valentine's Day. Easy to make and deliciously addicting! #chocolatechip #valentinesday

A few weeks ago we had company coming over and I made two dips. My Reese’s Peanut Butter Dip and this Valentine’s Day dip. Hopefully my friends are getting used to the idea that we eat holiday treats a month before the actual event.

This dip was very easy to make. Unlike the Reese’s Dip, you want to refrigerate this one for an hour or two to let the cream cheese, butter and sugars harden a little bit. That way you can shape it and cover it with sprinkles.

Chocolate Chip Toffee Dip for Valentine's Day. Easy to make and deliciously addicting! #chocolatechip #valentinesday

I have no trick, by the way, for covering this with sprinkles. I first wrapped it in plastic wrap and stuck it in the refrigerator for 1 1/2 hours. I laid a piece of parchment paper on my serving dish and removed the cheeseball from the wrap and put it on the paper. I then patted the sprinkles onto the cheeseball. Yes, my hands were sticky. Yes, sprinkles fell off and went all over the serving plate. When it was done, I tilted the plate and let the sprinkles fall off onto another plate on the counter. I saved my sprinkles (they were perfect to use in homemade confetti cupcakes). You could throw them away though, or repeat the patting process with them!

At this point, EAT. I used pretzels, animal cracker and graham sticks to serve. However, the leftovers were great with Crunchpak apple slices! I wish I had served apples in the first place! The toffee bits in this dip really stood out and made it irresistible! So addicting!

Chocolate Chip Toffee Dip for Valentine's Day. Easy to make and deliciously addicting! #chocolatechip #valentinesday

Love this recipe? Find more delicious recipes by following me on Pinterest:

Valentine Love

Fudge Truffles and Candy

Cheesecake Heaven

Don’t miss another mouthwatering recipe from Shugary Sweets! Be sure to follow me:

 Facebook | Twitter | Google+ | Pinterest | Bloglovin’

Toffee Chocolate Chip Valentine’s Day Cheeseball


  • 8 oz cream cheese, softened
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
  • 3/4 cup powdered sugar
  • 2 Tbsp brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup mini semi-sweet chocolate morsels
  • 1/2 cup toffee bits (Heath)
  • sprinkles


  1. In a large mixing bowl, beat cream cheese and butter until fluffy, about 3 minutes. Add both sugars and beat until completely blended. Stir in morsels and toffee bits.
  2. Wrap mixture in a large piece of plastic wrap and refrigerate for 1-2 hours. If desired, lay on serving tray and shape into a heart, cover with sprinkles!
  3. **optional: you can also cover this in chopped nuts or additional mini chocolate chips

Chocolate Chip Toffee Dip for Valentine's Day. Easy to make and deliciously addicting!

67 comments on “Toffee Chocolate Chip Valentine’s Day Cheeseball”

  1. Beautiful! Sounds perfect for a party!

  2. ohmygod. I just. I don’t even – what do I say in response to this magnificent cheese ball? Is it too old of a reference to merely shout GET IN MY BELLY!!?

  3. April

    This sounds amazing, especially with apples!! Yum!! This might have to be our after school snack too!

  4. This looks soo good. Can I bring over my apple slices?

  5. Oh Aimee this is SO beautiful! What a perfect treat for a Valentine’s Party or just to snack on with loved ones. Love it!

  6. I remember getting all the sprinkles like that on my PB football. A little work, but so worth it. This is amazing Aimee! I wouldn’t share, not at all!

  7. Hand over the animal crackers! I want some of that dip!! Looks so cute for Valentine’s Day

  8. Ok Aimee. This is so great!! I just want to keep staring at the photos. I bet my kids would love this as well!

  9. Great idea!! You got me thinking! This would make such a wonderful spread to serve on V-day!!

  10. Looks gorgeous Aimee! If I had this waiting for my kids as an after school snack, they would think they’ve died and gone to heaven! Yummy! I may make it for myself as an “after they leave for school snack”!

  11. This is AWESOME!!! So, so pretty! Happy Valentine’s Day 🙂

  12. You had me at toffee, my friend! Thanks so much for sharing, Aimee!


  13. OMG. I just want to jump through the screen and eat the entire thing in one sitting! It looks so fantastic! Aaaaand, now I really want to make a cannoli cheeseball. You’re giving me all sorts of crazy ideas 😉

  14. Oh, this needs to happen in my kitchen ASAP!

  15. Girl you are killing me with all these awesome dips! Can I come live with you? 🙂 I need this in life. And how cute to shape it into a heart. I think everyone in our lives are used to us serving them holiday food the month before the actual holiday! #foodbloggerproblems

  16. My son would LOVE this sweet cheeseball. I’m pretty sure I need to have this waiting for him after school on Thursday. Yep. It’s settled. I do. 🙂

  17. oh my Aimee! You did it again! I love toffee! I love chocolate! I love cheesecake! Put them all together and you’ve got me on my knees begging for some! Delicious!

  18. OH EM GEE!! This heart of goodness looks AMAZING! I seriously want to take a bite now and will definitely be making this for an upcoming party! Pinning ! 🙂

  19. This is just what I needed. A large heart shaped slab of cream cheese and sugar. It really isn’t Valentine’s Day without it.

  20. I gain 10 pounds when I visit your site just by reading what you made! Love this one!!

  21. I love toffee! This sounds super tasty (even if I’m way too lazy to shape this into a heart :))

  22. Love this idea. the heart is so pretty and festive!

  23. This looks absolutely DELICIOUS! Thanks for sharing! Smiles, Jill

  24. Aimee, are you kidding me with this cuteness?!? This is the most adorable cheeseball I’ve ever laid eyes on {wait until I get my lips around it…LOL!}. Looks amazing. I so, so wish our school allowed homemade treats…because I would totally bring this to both kids’ parties. SUPER awesome.

  25. Liz

    Your dip is beautiful Aimee! I’m sure it tastes delicious too 🙂

  26. I have a weakness for dips, especially ones that have toffee and chocolate chips in them. I love the heart shape too, so cute!

  27. You totes outdid yourself, girl. This cheeseball is INSANE.

  28. Loooooving the sprinkle action here.

  29. Oh my! How cute and delicious does this look?!

  30. Ok this is completely out of control is the very best way possible. I’ve been seeing this all over Pinterest the past 2 days Aimee! LOVING all of these sprinkles 😉

  31. Meg @ Sweet Twist

    I will be making this dip for sure. I love toffee bits. So delicious.

  32. 580065 451461I enjoy your writing style really enjoying this web site . 664320

  33. Valerie

    I made this for my husband’s 50th surprise birthday party and it was a BIG hit! People were hesitant to eat it at first but when the first person dug in, it was full speed ahead. All I kept hearing was, “What is that!” My 17 y/o nephew made another one last night. It is addictive!!! Thanks so much; I can’t wait to try all of them….

  34. Pingback: 14 Heart Recipes for Valentine's Day - Blessed Beyond A Doubt

  35. This is beautiful and sounds tasty but I’ve never heard of toffee bits before. Are they something you buy in the baking section?

  36. Pingback: Let's Live Love Laugh » Celebrating Life » Chocolate Grilled Cheese Is A Thing…And Yes It’s As Amazing As It Sounds

  37. Pingback: leftvip » Chocolate Grilled Cheese Is A Thing…And Yes It’s As Amazing As It Sounds

  38. Pingback: Turtle Cheeseball - Shugary Sweets

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.