Skip the packaged candy and make Peanut Butter Cups at home! Easy Homemade Reese’s have all the irresistible taste of the original, without any of the preservatives. Only 4 ingredients!
Copycat Reese’s Peanut butter Cups
For most of us, a Reese’s Peanut Butter cup was our first introduction to this beloved pairing when we were kids.
At Halloween, Reese’s was always in high demand during trick-or-treating. Last time my kids went trick-or-treating, that was definitely still the case.
Making copycat recipes of my favorite candy is something of a compulsion for me.
Sure, Reese’s aren’t exactly a gourmet luxury. You can find them inexpensively just about everywhere.
So you might be wondering: Why make your own Reese’s?
First things first: because it’s fun! You can pat yourself on the back and feel accomplished WHILE eating tasty peanut butter cups, too, so it’s a win-win.
Most importantly, though: Homemade Peanut Butter Cups taste SO much better than the packaged kind. The chocolate is richer, the peanut butter. . . well, peanuttier. These homemade Reese’s are just plain more delicious.
And even though no one is under the delusion that Peanut Butter Cups are a health food, it’s nice to know that your homemade ones aren’t laden with all kinds of preservatives and unidentifiable ingredients.
This peanut butter cups recipe has just 4 ingredients:
- chocolate melting wafers
- peanut butter
- powdered sugar
- vanilla extract
You don’t need any special equipment either (just a cupcake pan and liners) and they come together easily.
Step by Step Instructions
STEP 1. Peanut butter filling
Combine the peanut butter, powdered sugar and vanilla in a bowl. Stir together well until the mixture is creamy and smooth. Transfer to a pastry bag or a ziploc bag with the corner snipped off.
STEP 2. Chocolate
Melt the chocolate candy wafers in the microwave. I recommend doing this in 30 second intervals, stirring between each one, until the candies are melted.
STEP 3. Assemble
Add two teaspoons of melted chocolate to the bottom of each cupcake liner. Next, pipe the peanut butter mixture from the frosting bag on top of the chocolate. Top this layer with one more tablespoon of melted chocolate.
STEP 4. Chill
Let the peanut butter cups set for one hour in the fridge before enjoying!
I use the Ghirardelli melting wafers for my peanut butter cups. They stay a little softer after firming up so, just like traditional Reese’s, they are easy to bite into and melt in your mouth.
You could also substitute chocolate chips for the Ghirardelli chocolate wafers. The chocolate will just be a little harder after setting.
Use creamy peanut butter for this peanut butter cup recipe. I recommend the shelf-stable kind for best texture, as opposed to the natural kind where the oil separates.
There are two ways you can store your batch of perfect homemade Reese’s cups: in the fridge or in the freezer.
To store in the fridge, transfer to an airtight container.
If you want to freeze them, place them in a freezer bag and squeeze out any excess air to maintain freshness. They’ll keep well in the freezer for as long as 6 months. That is, if you can somehow resist eating them all before then.
Tips and Tricks
- This recipe can also be made using a mini-muffin pan for bite sized treats. If you use a mini pan, I recommend putting just one teaspoon of melted chocolate on the bottom of the cups instead of two, and two teaspoons on top.
- Making these for a party, holiday or special occasion? Add sprinkles on top for a festive touch!
- Want something a little different? Try substituting almond butter or your other favorite nut butter for the peanut butter.
I’m so thrilled with how these turned out! Now that you know how easy (and scrumptious) homemade peanut butter cups are, you might never buy Reese’s from the store again.
(Except on Halloween. Gotta keep those trick-or-treaters happy.)
Just one more tip: Kids love these homemade Reese’s cups so make sure you hide a few in the back of the fridge just for yourself. Everyone needs to indulge in chocolate-peanut butter bliss from time to time. Enjoy!