Chocolate Cake Shake

Sharing is caring!

Chocolate Cake Shake: blended ice cream with chocolate frosted cake #copycat #portillos
Every family has its quirks. Some of those quirks you think are just normal, until of course other’s point out those quirks as “odd” or “flawed” or just plain “weird.”
I grew up thinking “cake soup” was normal. 
Birthdays were an awesome time, not because of the presents, but because of the plain chocolate cakes with white frosting. That we ate in a bowl. With milk poured onto it.
Yes, cake soup.
There were a few cousins and others in the family who thought it was odd, but for the most part, this is just what my family did.
Then I went out in the real world. And in the real world, apparantly, people don’t eat birthday cake in bowls. With milk. In the real world, people like their cake on a plate, with a glass of milk. Talk about odd.
I would TRY so hard to make people understand, and taste my “cake soup.” 
Most of the time I just got weird looks.
Then, one glorious day last year, my brother told me about Cake Shakes. From Portillo’s. Portillo’s is the BEST fast food in Chicagoland, with the BEST Italian beef sammies, french fries and chocolate cake.
Guess what they did with that chocolate cake?
Yep, they blended it right into a chocolate shake.
Want to know what it tastes like?
Chocolate Cake Shake: blended ice cream with chocolate frosted cake #copycat #portillos
A bowl of cake soup. 
Finally, I feel like people get me. When they give me strange stares, all I have to say is, “it tastes like a Portillo’s cake shake.”
Next time you make a cake, instead of throwing away the leftovers (do people do that?) or eating them all at once (that’s what I do), stick a few slices of cake in the freezer. For this moment. You will thank me.
And start eating your cake in a bowl with a big splash of milk. Be sure to pass that tradition on to your children!
Like this recipe? check out these….
Caramel Coffee Milkshakes by Shugary Sweets
Pumpkin Pie Milkshakes by Tidy Mom
Chocolate Chip Cookie Kahlua Milkshakes by How Sweet It Is
Yield: 2 servings

Chocolate Cake Shake

Chocolate Cake Shake
Prep Time 5 minutes


  • 6 scoops chocolate icecream
  • 1 big slice (about 2 cup) chocolate cake, prepared with chocolate frosting
  • splash of milk


  1. In a blender, combine ice cream with chocolate cake, crumbled. Add milk and blend. Makes two servings. ENJOY!

**There may be affiliate links in this post! By clicking on them, or purchasing recommended items I may receive a small compensation. However, I only recommend products I love! Thank you for supporting Shugary Sweets! See my disclosure policy for more info**

61 comments on “Chocolate Cake Shake”

  1. My parents & siblings always did that! They, in turn, passed it on to my children.

    I don’t think it’s weird. It’s normal to some of us!

  2. Brilliant! I can’t wait to try this!!

  3. My little brother loooooves chocolate cake shakes from Portillo’s! His bday is around the corner so I think I figured out his present! I am a huge Portillo’s fan too! Love their cheese fries, beef, hot dogs, even the chopped salad are all so good!

  4. This looks perfect! My dad always eats pie, cake, etc. with milk on it…that’s more common than I thought!

  5. Yummy! I can’t wait to try this! it looks deliciousss

  6. I made a cake batter milkshake a few weeks ago – you used real cake. I LOVE the way you think! NICE!!!

  7. I love this! That combination of delicious ingredients can never be bad or weird 🙂

  8. I have never heard of eating cake cake-soup style, but I’m definitely eager to try it now! It actually sounds good to me, and so does this gorgeous milkshake! I love that big ol’ hunk of chocolate cake nesting on the side. Looks way better than any orange hanging off the side of a glass, don’t ya think? 🙂

  9. This is too good! It has definitely never crossed my mind to throw actual cake, frosting and all, into a blender….And the cake soup thing? If its in a bowl, you can eat it for breakfast right? 😉

  10. Yum yum yum! I make these all the time 🙂

  11. My husband does the cake soup thing and I just never liked it. I just don’t like a soggy cake soup. But everyone has their quirks. I love dipping my Wendy’s fries in the chocolate frosty. Heavenly!

  12. Cake shakes are awesome. I used to get them from Sheridan’s in Kansas. White Wedding Cake shake, red velvet with chocolate jimmies, lemon bar shakes, they are truly so delicious 🙂 Loving the chocolate cake variety you made!

  13. Haha, what?! I love this. I’ve never heard of such a thing but it sounds good to me! And I love how you used a piece of cake as garnish. Amazing. 🙂

  14. what a delish idea! Thank you for sharing. I enjoyed my visit to your lovely blog. Hugs. P.S. I invite you to join us for tomorrows linky party ( blog hop)

  15. holy crap, that chocolate cake looks SO good on that shake. i’ll take that hunk of cake and the shake please!! haha

  16. Okay AImee, I’ve never heard of cake soup, but I totally want to try it!! That shake looks amazing and now I want cake!!!

  17. HOLY FRIDGE I LOVE love lovveeee portillos! Their chocolate cake shake is beyond heavenly. I got so excited when I saw this!! I love it when people actually know what POrtillo’s is. Have you tried their chopped salad?! It’s pretty much the only place I ever get excited about ordering a salad from. I have no idea what they do to that thing, but it is GOOD. Of course their hot dogs and beef are killer too 😉

  18. You aren’t weird, I used to do this too!!!! I wouldn’t blend it though, I liked mine with chunky pieces of cake. It’s super awesome!

  19. cake soup sounds pretty enthralling :o) this cake shake…wow!!

  20. Anonymous

    what no Jello in the soup???

  21. I totally done this with my cake and sponge as a kid and would even wait until my ice cream had completely melted so I could mix it together. Maybe that’s why I love tres leches so much?

  22. I have always done this with brownies, but cake looks even better

  23. My nephew’s birthday was a couple days ago and I wanted the leftover chocolate cake to smoosh up & make into choc cake ice cream. I got some ‘looks’ as well. Seeing these tasty pics – I wish I had!

  24. Love the cake balancing on the side!! My family is certainly quickly. We don’t have cake soup, but I’d be willing to give it a try! I suspect my kids would think it’s the best thing ever!

  25. Thought that was something only my family did with day old cake. Nice to have a name for it, Cake soup!! Can’t wait to try the shake.

  26. Anonymous

    I totally eat cake soup too!!!! I’m so glad to hear that I’m not the only one in this world who likes it. 🙂

  27. I LOVE this picture! And the recipe 🙂 There was a place called Sammy’s in Provo, and they did pie and cupcake shakes. SO GOOD! You literally watched them scoop out the ice cream, shove your gigantic slice of pie in the shake cup, and then blend the mess outta that thing. It was so awesome. This takes me back 🙂

  28. This sounds like a wonderful idea! Definitely worthy of a tradition! 🙂

  29. What an awesome post & recipe! We all do have our quirks huh? I love special traditions. You have SUCH a knack with making special desserts. Thanks soooo much for linking this up at Weekend Potluck. VERY special!

  30. Amanda

    I’m totally drooling over the cake garnish – the frosting looks so rich and glossy! Is it just buttercream, or something fancier?
    I feel like I need to go make a cake JUST to make a shake…

  31. This is AMAZING! I love your tip about freezing a few pieces of the chocolate cake! (=

  32. This sounds so wonderful! I’ll be featuring it at the party tonight! Hope you stop by to check it out (starts at 8

  33. MariaR

    Hi Amiee! Will you be my friend? This recipe is proof you will fit in perfectly with all my friends 🙂 We are a little confused about the leftover cake… it’s like leftover wine, we’ve never heard of it!

  34. Heather

    I love the Portillo’s Chocolate Cake Shake too! I know you can use any kind of chocolate (or other flavor as mentioned above) cake for this, but Portillo’s does use a chocolate mayonnaise cake. I had never heard of mayonnaise being in a chocolate cake before I had it there. So moist and yummy!

  35. This looks absolutely incredible! Thank you for sharing!

  36. Elaine Ellen

    We did that a lot in high school. Actually we put the pieces of cake in our glasses of milk because it was kind of dry. It was very good that way! People dunk cookies, why would cake soup be so weird?

  37. Pingback: Frosted Gooey Chocolate Cake Bars - Shugary Sweets

  38. Karen Kay

    My brother-in-law owns a restaurant and has pie shakes on the menu for years!

  39. jann jones

    Cake soup… Ya know, I was devouring chocolate cake, in its many delectable varieties, in a bowl with milk in the ’50s, with mom.. We didn’t wait for it to be cooled, or frosted, and it RARELY got stale, or hard, we’d just whack out a chunk, into a bowl, grab that milk, and yummmmmm… Never knew there was a name for it…. But, oh, wow, have I had a craving lately.. Comfort food from the gods!!! Have a big bite for me!!

  40. Pingback: Blueberry Muffin Milkshake - Will Cook For Smiles

  41. Pingback: Chocolate Cake Shake | Chocolate

  42. Sara

    Growing up we put our cake right in a glass of milk. I preferred a tall glass of Nestle’s Quik with my cake. I still eat it today as a special treat. Mom said, “this was how we ate stale cake and crackers during the depression.”

  43. DeeDee

    People always think I’m crazy because I love to take a bowl of cake & ice cream and immediately smash all of it together until it’s just cake ice cream. Sooooooo good!

  44. Pingback: Neapolitan Cheesecake Cake - Shugary Sweets

  45. Adorable

    I adore that???? it keeps me happy

  46. Pingback: Frosted Chocolate Nut Cookie Bars - Shugary Sweets

  47. Pingback: Easy, Frosted Gooey Chocolate Cake Bars Recipe

  48. Pingback: Perfect Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Buttercream Frosting Recipe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.